Clash of Civilization Article

MEDIA EDUCATION

FOUNDATION To R A N H C 3rd there’s r I REHABILITATION

EDWARD STATED

THE MY OWN TH OF ‘ THE CLASH OF CIVILIZATIONS'

Demanding media

EDWARD SAID

The Myth of ‘The Clash of Civilizations'

Executive Producer & Director: Sut Jhally Manager: Sanjay Talreja Featuring a address by Edward Said Mentor, Columbia University and writer of Orientalism Introduced by simply Sut Jhally University of Massachusetts-Amherst

Mass media Education Foundation В© MEF1998

2 PORTION ONE – INTRODUCTION Thank you very much. I'm going to begin, in fact , discuss throughout regarding an dissertation and a book written by Samuel Huntington titled The Clash of Cultures. When it premoere appearance in 93 in the log Foreign Affairs, it had a question mark after it and it announced in really first sentence in your essay that community politics is entering a fresh phase. 36 months later Huntington expanded the essay, a few would claim bloated it, to the scale a book with no question mark. The newest book that has been published a year ago, entitled The Clash of Civilizations as well as the Emerging Globe Order. My premise is usually that the essay surpasses the book. I mean that got worse the more this individual added to this. So Items concentrate almost all of my focus on the composition but generate some remarks about the book even as we go along. Right now, what Huntington meant when he said that globe politics was entering a brand new phase was that whereas recently world clashes had been among ideological camps, grouping the first, second and third worlds in warring entities, the new style of politics which will he discerned would include conflicts among different and presumably clashing civilizations. My spouse and i quote him, " The fantastic divisions amongst humankind as well as the dominating supply of conflict will be cultural. The clash of civilizations is going to dominate global politics. " Later this individual explains just how it is that the principal battle will be between Western and non European civilization, but he spends most of his time in both the works, talking about the disagreements, potential or perhaps actual, between what this individual calls the West on the other hand, and on the other, Islamic and Confucian civilizations. When it comes to detail, considerably more attention, aggressive attention, is usually paid to Islam than to any additional civilization such as the West. In much of the great interest eventually taken in Huntington's essay, I believe derives from the timing instead of exclusively coming from what it says. As he him self notes, there are several intellectual and politics attempts because the end from the Cold War to map the appearing world circumstance, and this involves Francis Fukuyama's thesis on the end of history, which usually nobody discusses, so the end of Fukuyama really. (laughter) And the thesis put regarding during the last mentioned days of the Bush Administration, the theory from the so-called New World Order. But , there have been more serious attempts to cope with the coming millennium in works by Paul Kennedy for example , Joshua Hobsbawm, significantly less interesting and more rabid Conor Cruise O'Brien, Robert Kaplan and an e book that's evidently making the rounds in campuses upon Jihad versus McWorld by Benjamin Klipper (daglig tale). All these ebooks have looked at the coming centuries with substantial attention to the causes of future turmoil, which has provided them all, I do believe justly, cause of alarm. The core of Huntington's vision, which is not genuinely original with him, may be the idea of an unceasing clash, a concept of conflict, which usually slides somewhat effortlessly in to the political space vacated by the unremitting war of tips and principles embodied inside the unregretted Chilly War that of course , Huntington, was a superb theorist. I actually don't think consequently it's incorrect to claim that what Huntington's providing in the work, especially since really primarily dealt with to powerfulk opinion and policy producers, is in

several fact a recycled edition of the Frosty War thesis that disputes in today's and tomorrow's globe will remain certainly not economic or perhaps social basically but ideological. And if that may be so , 1 ideology, the West, is definitely the still...